Sellfy vs Gumroad

Sellfy works as a subscription of $22 to $119 a month billed yearly, with a 0% transaction fee and a yearly sales cap on every plan. Gumroad has no monthly charge and keeps 10% plus $0.50 of direct sales, or 30% when its Discover marketplace brings the buyer. On tax, Gumroad says it acts as merchant of record, while Sellfy lists advanced VAT and tax settings among its plan features. The price of each sale decides most of the choice, since a cheap download sold steadily costs far less on the flat plan. An empty month costs nothing on Gumroad.

Vendors can pay for more visibility on this website, for example a higher place in a ranking or more room on a page. Commercial relationships can also affect which products we feature and how prominently. Every vendor link is marked the same, whatever the arrangement behind it. How that works.

01

Sellfy and Gumroad side by side

SellfyGumroad
Our creator monetization platform rank#2 of 12#6 of 12
Established inLithuaniaUnited States
List price, 18 November 2026Starter $22, Business $59, Premium $119 a month on yearly billing ($29, $79, $159 monthly); 0% transaction fee; yearly sales caps of $10,000, $50,000 and $200,000Nothing monthly; each sale through a profile or direct link costs 10% + $0.50, and 30% when Discover brings the buyer
Free tier——
Open source——
Self-hostable——
Built forCreators selling digital products who want a predictable bill instead of a percentageSellers of files and courses who want no fixed monthly charge
Not forCreators with unpredictable sales who cannot afford a monthly commitmentStores with high volume of cheap items or discovery-dependent sales

Both are reviewed in full in our creator monetization platform ranking: Sellfy and Gumroad.

02

Where they differ

Sellfy 2 · Gumroad 3 · open 1
  1. 01

    Who deals with sales tax

    Gumroad's page says that since January 1, 2025 it handles all tax obligations as merchant of record, collecting and remitting sales tax worldwide where it has obligations, and its dashboard tax settings are switched off. Sellfy's table lists advanced VAT and tax settings on all three plans, which reads as tools the seller operates. Sellfy's pricing page does not explain who files returns. A seller who dislikes tax paperwork finds the clearer answer at Gumroad, at the cost of the percentage.

    Edge: Gumroad

  2. 02

    A $15 e-book sold fifty times a month

    On direct links Gumroad takes 10% plus $0.50, which is $2.00 on a $15 product, so fifty sales a month cost $100, or $1,200 a year. The same $9,000 of yearly sales sits inside the Starter cap, where Sellfy asks $264 a year on yearly billing and charges 0% per transaction. Stripe or PayPal fees come on top at Sellfy, paid to them. For cheap items at steady volume, the flat plan keeps more of each sale.

    Edge: Sellfy

  3. 03

    A month with nothing sold

    Gumroad states that it charges no monthly fee and earns only when you do, so an empty month leaves the balance untouched. Sellfy bills Starter at $29 monthly or $22 a month on yearly billing whatever the sales. Sellfy softens the entry with a two-week trial plus a full refund within 30 days of an upgrade. A hobby seller or someone testing a product idea carries less risk on Gumroad than on any Sellfy plan.

    Edge: Gumroad

  4. 04

    The yearly cap Sellfy sets

    Each Sellfy plan has a yearly sales ceiling: $10,000 on Starter, $50,000 on Business and $200,000 on Premium. Sellers who pass it are expected to upgrade, and until they do Sellfy may charge 2% on sales above the limit, while the store keeps running. Beyond $200,000 a year the page invites a contact for a high-volume offer. Gumroad's page names no ceiling of that kind, so growth there raises the fee in proportion instead of forcing a step.

    Edge: Gumroad

  5. 05

    Marketing kit against marketplace

    Sellfy includes email marketing on every plan, with 2,000, 10,000 and 50,000 free credits, plus coupons and customer reviews. Business adds upselling, cart abandonment and an affiliate programme, and drops the Sellfy branding. Gumroad offers its Discover marketplace, where a sale to a new customer costs 30%, and lists memberships among what you can sell. Which side wins depends on whether you bring your own audience or need strangers to find the product in the first place.

    Depends on the buyer

  6. 06

    What the shop can hold

    Sellfy covers digital downloads, subscriptions, print-on-demand and physical products, with up to 50 files per digital product and files up to 10 GB on Starter, 15 GB on Business and 20 GB on Premium. Gumroad's page lists digital products, e-books, courses, tutorials and memberships, and its list of items that cannot be sold begins with physical goods. A seller mixing merchandise with downloads in one store has the wider options at Sellfy, which also lists print-on-demand beside downloads.

    Edge: Sellfy

03

When neither fits

If recurring fan support matters more than product sales, look at Patreon or Buy Me a Coffee instead. Both appear in our creator monetization research. Check their fee tables against your expected income before comparing them with the two above.

04

Sellfy or Gumroad: questions

3 answers
Is a Sellfy plan ever worse value than a quiet Gumroad year?

Yes, when few sales come in. Starter costs $264 a year on yearly billing, or $348 at $29 a month, even if nothing sells.

Gumroad's fees on a $15 direct sale come to $2.00, so Starter starts to cost less after roughly 132 such sales a year.

Does a Sellfy store go offline when it outgrows its plan?

The pricing page says the store keeps running. Sellfy may charge 2% on revenue above the plan limit until you upgrade, and says it will notify you on reaching the maximum. Above $200,000 a year it invites you to ask about a high-volume offer.

Who pays the card processor on each platform?

Sellfy states that Stripe or PayPal charge their usual processing rates, that this money goes to them and not to Sellfy, and that payouts go straight to your own account.

Gumroad's page lists only its own 10% plus $0.50 or 30%, and says payout by direct deposit or PayPal varies by country. Whether Gumroad's percentage already covers processing is not stated in the text we read.

—

Sources

Checked 18 November 2026
  • Sellfy plans and FAQ: monthly and yearly rates, sales caps and 2% overage, email credits, file sizes, tax settings row, Stripe and PayPal processing note.
  • Gumroad pricing: 10% + $0.50 and 30% Discover rates, no monthly fee, merchant of record from January 1, 2025, items not allowed.
—

More comparisons