Caddy vs NGINX
Caddy turns on HTTPS by default and fetches and renews its own certificates, with a Caddyfile that stays short for common reverse proxy jobs. nginx is the older engine, with a wider protocol list (mail, TCP and UDP proxying) and enterprise distributions sold by F5. Caddy is Apache-2.0 and funds support through sponsorships with published monthly tiers. nginx is 2-clause BSD, and F5's commercial prices do not appear on any page we opened. Neither vendor states a country of establishment. Its reverse proxy directive lists health checks and dynamic upstreams.
Vendors can pay for more visibility on this website, for example a higher place in a ranking or more room on a page. Commercial relationships can also affect which products we feature and how prominently. Every vendor link is marked the same, whatever the arrangement behind it. How that works.
you want certificates handled without extra setup and a config you can read in a few lines. You also want a runtime API for changing routes while the server runs.
you need mail proxying or generic TCP and UDP balancing in the same binary. You may also want an F5 support contract behind a server your team already knows.
Caddy and NGINX side by side
| Caddy | NGINX | |
|---|---|---|
| Our reverse proxy software rank | #1 of 14 | #11 of 14 |
| Established in | Not stated by the vendor | Not stated by the vendor |
| List price, 14 November 2026 | Open source with no paywalled features; sponsorship tiers fund support: Individual Indie $25, Pro $50, Startup $99, Business $999, Business+ $2,999, Enterprise $5,900, Enterprise+ $11,900 a month | 2-clause BSD download at no charge; enterprise distributions, commercial support and training sold by F5, quoted with no figures on the pages we read |
| Free tier | Yes | — |
| Open source | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hostable | Yes | — |
| Built for | Lean teams that want HTTPS and a reverse proxy running within an afternoon | Teams that want a mainstream proxy they can install on almost any system |
| Not for | Anyone who wants a vendor-hosted service rather than their own server | Procurement needing a priced NGINX support plan they can check online |
Both are reviewed in full in our reverse proxy software ranking: Caddy and NGINX.
Where they differ
Caddy 3 · NGINX 2 · open 1- 01
Certificates without a plugin
Caddy's docs say it obtains and renews TLS certificates for all your sites by default and redirects HTTP to HTTPS, and that it has done so since 2015. nginx has an ACME module implementing ACMEv2, but its example config needs a resolver, an issuer block, a state path, accepted terms and a port 80 listener for challenges. Caddy needs noticeably less wiring to reach a working HTTPS site. That gap matters most for teams running many small sites.
Edge: Caddy
- 02
Protocols outside HTTP
nginx's front page describes an HTTP server, reverse proxy, content cache, load balancer, TCP and UDP proxy and mail proxy for IMAP, POP3 and SMTP, plus HTTP/3 and the njs scripting language. The Caddy pages we read cover HTTP reverse proxying with active and passive health checks, dynamic upstreams and h2c backends. For a mail proxy or a generic TCP front, nginx lists what we could not find on Caddy's pages. Caddy's repository describes it as an HTTP/1-2-3 web server.
Edge: NGINX
- 03
Changing config while it runs
Caddy's native configuration is a JSON document that its site says you can export and manipulate through a RESTful config API, alongside the human-friendly Caddyfile. The nginx pages we read describe configuration through directives in files, and its front page names no config API. If a platform has to push route changes automatically without editing and reloading files, Caddy's page describes the mechanism directly. That is the main configuration difference we found between the two sites, and it favours Caddy for automated setups.
Edge: Caddy
- 04
Money and the licence
Caddy is Apache-2.0 on GitHub, and its sponsor page says it has no paywalled features. Support comes through sponsorship: Pro at $50 a month, Business at $999, Business+ at $2,999 and Enterprise at $5,900. nginx is 2-clause BSD, and its site says enterprise distributions, commercial support and training come from F5. F5's purchase page we read shows no figures, so Caddy is easier to budget for. Both are free to download and run. Support is where money enters.
Edge: Caddy
- 05
Who stands behind the support
The Caddy sponsor page puts a response promise on its two top tiers: two business days on Enterprise and one on Enterprise+. Lower tiers list occasional email support and triage priority. nginx points buyers to F5, which has subscription and perpetual licensing pages, though the terms are not published on what we read. A company wanting a named vendor with a sales channel may find F5 the more familiar counterparty. The page also warns that top tiers can sell out.
Edge: NGINX
- 06
Where each project is documented
Caddy's site carries a Caddyfile reference, a JSON config reference, tutorials, an examples section and a registered module list, with a forum linked from the header. nginx.org carries module-by-module reference pages, a downloads page with stable and mainline releases, books, a community forum and a security page. Both are thorough. nginx's reference is organised by module, which suits an engineer who already knows what to look up. Neither site showed a documentation gap on the pages opened, and the winner is a draw.
Depends on the buyer
When neither fits
If you need a proxy aimed at container orchestration, or a dedicated load balancer, look at Traefik. HAProxy is the other name in our reverse proxy ranking worth checking for that job.
Caddy or NGINX: questions
3 answersIs there anything in Caddy that sits behind a paid licence?
Its sponsor page says there are no paywalled features and that sponsorships fund support instead. The listed tiers buy private support, training access and priority, not extra functions.
That reads differently from nginx, where F5 sells enterprise distributions, though we saw no figures on its pages.
Can nginx get certificates automatically too?
Yes, through the ngx_http_acme_module described on nginx.org, which implements ACMEv2 and is available as a prebuilt package.
The module's example needs more directives than Caddy's default behaviour, including a challenge listener on port 80. The page also lists a Plus package as part of the commercial subscription since 1.29.0.
Which one suits a mail proxy in front of IMAP servers?
nginx, going by its front page: it lists a mail proxy with IMAP, POP3 and SMTP authentication and STARTTLS support.
The Caddy pages we opened describe HTTP reverse proxying and do not mention a mail proxy. Check Caddy's module list if that is a hard requirement.
Sources
Checked 14 November 2026- Caddy home page: automatic HTTPS by default, JSON config API, On-Demand TLS.
- Caddy sponsorship page: monthly tier prices, no paywalled features, response promises on the top two tiers.
- Caddy reverse_proxy documentation: active and passive health checking, dynamic upstreams, h2c backends.
- Caddy GitHub repository: Apache-2.0 licence.
- nginx.org home page: 2-clause BSD licence, mail, TCP and UDP proxying, HTTP/3, enterprise distributions from F5.
- nginx ACME module documentation: ACMEv2 module, example directives, prebuilt package, Plus package since 1.29.0.