PlanSource vs Employee Navigator

These two sell benefits administration to different buyers. PlanSource speaks to HR and benefits leaders, and to carriers and resellers, and wraps the platform in services such as COBRA, consumer health accounts and an employee service centre. Employee Navigator addresses insurance brokers on its pricing page and sells four named plans, Enhanced to Platinum, each priced through a sales contact. Neither page we read shows an amount for the platform itself. The plainest published number is Employee Navigator's $0.45 per employee per month for 834 EDI carrier feeds on two of its plans.

Vendors can pay for more visibility on this website, for example a higher place in a ranking or more room on a page. Commercial relationships can also affect which products we feature and how prominently. Every vendor link is marked the same, whatever the arrangement behind it. How that works.

01

PlanSource and Employee Navigator side by side

PlanSourceEmployee Navigator
Our benefits administration software rank#2 of 13#4 of 13
Established inUnited StatesUnited States
List price, 12 November 2026Demo request only; the pages we read list no plan names or amountsEnhanced, Enhanced Plus, Elite and Platinum plans, each on Contact Sales; 834 EDI feeds $0.45 PEPM on two plans, $0 on Platinum
Free tier——
Open source——
Self-hostable——
Built forHR teams wanting software and a service desk from one supplierBrokers running enrolment for many small and mid-sized employer clients
Not forBrokers needing a white-label tool for many clientsEmployers wanting to buy and trial it directly

Both are reviewed in full in our benefits administration software ranking: PlanSource and Employee Navigator.

02

Where they differ

PlanSource 2 · Employee Navigator 3 · open 1
  1. 01

    Who the pricing page is written for

    Employee Navigator's pricing page opens with plans designed for brokers of all sizes and talks about managing benefits for all of a broker's clients, with unlimited companies and unlimited employees listed on every plan. PlanSource's home page splits its audience into HR and benefits leaders, carriers and partners, and reseller partners. A broker shop will read Employee Navigator as written for it. An in-house HR team gets a more direct route into PlanSource, with its own page.

    Depends on the buyer

  2. 02

    Named tiers against a single demo button

    Employee Navigator names four plans, Enhanced, Enhanced Plus, Elite and Platinum, and sets out what each adds in a comparison grid, although every plan carries a Contact Sales button instead of an amount. PlanSource's pages we read carry a Request a Demo button and nothing on plan names or prices. A buyer can at least see how Employee Navigator's packages step up before speaking to anyone, which makes early budgeting and internal sign-off a little easier.

    Edge: Employee Navigator

  3. 03

    The 834 file fee

    Employee Navigator prints one real number: 834 EDI feeds cost $0.45 per employee per month on Enhanced Plus and on Elite, and the Platinum plan shows $0 PEPM for them, with a footnote that additional fees apply. PlanSource's pages describe carrier billing and payment workflows and cleaner data between plans and carriers, yet we read no EDI rate there. For anyone sending enrollment files to many carriers, Employee Navigator at least states the unit cost up front.

    Edge: Employee Navigator

  4. 04

    COBRA, HSA and child support orders

    PlanSource lists extended services on its platform page: COBRA administration, consumer health accounts covering HSAs, FSAs, HRAs and LSAs, QMCSO administration, ACA administration, dependent verification and an employee service centre. The Employee Navigator pricing and home pages we read cover ACA reporting, with 1095 and 1094 reporting flagged as carrying additional fees, but do not name COBRA or QMCSO work. If the compliance back office is part of the buying decision, PlanSource shows more of it.

    Edge: PlanSource

  5. 05

    HR tools around enrollment

    Employee Navigator's Elite plan adds new hire onboarding, recurring task management, PTO and vacation tracking and AMS integrations, and its navigation also lists HR management and integrated payroll, with 600+ integrations claimed. PlanSource's platform page we read stays on benefits: total rewards statements, communications, verification and billing. Time-off tracking or onboarding checklists were not on the pages we read. A company wanting those in the same login sees them on the Employee Navigator side, at the Elite tier.

    Edge: Employee Navigator

  6. 06

    AI claims and who answers the phone

    PlanSource describes agentic and generative AI for dependent verification, implementation configuration, reporting and a virtual assistant, with human support kept in the loop. Employee Navigator lists AI Plan Builds on all four plans, but its priority phone support appears only on Platinum, while email and phone support carries an asterisk on the other tiers. PlanSource spells out more of what its AI does, whereas Employee Navigator ties faster phone help to its top plan only.

    Edge: PlanSource

03

When neither fits

If you are a small employer who wants a broker-run service rather than a vendor demo, Lumity is in our category as a broker-run option. For a package whose entry price is published, look at Namely, which lists a per employee per month starting price.

04

PlanSource or Employee Navigator: questions

3 answers
Does either vendor publish what the platform costs per employee?

Not on the pages we read. Employee Navigator names four plans with a sales contact behind every one, and PlanSource routes buyers to a demo request.

The only amount we saw is Employee Navigator's $0.45 per employee per month for 834 EDI feeds on Enhanced Plus and Elite.

Which one speaks directly to insurance brokers?

Employee Navigator. Its pricing page is titled around brokers and it quotes 7,000+ brokers and 195,000+ employers on the home page. PlanSource also has a reseller partner route, but its main message is for HR and benefits leaders.

Where are the two companies based?

Employee Navigator lists an address in Bethesda, Maryland, while PlanSource lists one in Orlando, Florida, under the name PlanSource Benefits Administration, Inc. Both addresses are in the United States. Neither page we read states hosting regions.

—

Sources

Checked 12 November 2026
—

More comparisons