PagerDuty alternatives: 11 incident management tools compared

The search for a PagerDuty alternative almost always starts with the invoice. Professional is listed at USD 21 per user per month on annual billing, and alert grouping is not part of it. Teams move to on-call tools that publish a lower seat price or bundle more into it, or to response platforms built around Slack and Microsoft Teams.

Short answer: The first three alternatives to PagerDuty in our incident management ranking are ilert, Xurrent IMR (formerly Zenduty) and All Quiet. Places 1 to 3 go to challengers, vendors outside the best-known brands in a category, wherever the category has them; the established names follow from place 4 in their ranked order. Choose ilert if you want hosting in Germany and a published price, and can live with grouping on the higher plan. All 11 alternatives below are ranked products from Best Incident Management Software in 2026, and each says where it differs from PagerDuty.

Vendors can pay for visibility on this site; it never changes what we say about a product. How that works.

PagerDuty

#10 of 13 in our incident management ranking

  • Pricing: Free plan up to 5 users; Professional per user per month, published; AIOps and automation priced separately
  • Established in: United States
  • Built for: Large estates where every tool must already have an integration
  • Not for: Teams whose main problem is the size of the on-call bill
01

Why buyers look past PagerDuty

  1. 01

    Responder seats are priced at the top of the market

    PagerDuty lists Professional at USD 21 per user per month billed annually, or USD 25 monthly, after a free plan for up to 5 users. All Quiet lists USD 4.99 with unlimited calls and SMS, Zenduty's successor Xurrent IMR starts at USD 6, and the former Squadcast at USD 15. For a team whose main problem is the on-call bill, that is the whole argument.

  2. 02

    Noise reduction is sold separately

    PagerDuty's own comparison marks alert grouping as not included in Professional. It comes with the separate AIOps add-on or with the PD Reliability Platform, whose Starter tier is listed at USD 2,800 a year for 10 seats. Teams that bought PagerDuty to cut noise find that feature priced apart from the seat, while Rootly and Xurrent IMR include grouping in listed plans.

  3. 03

    Paging is only the first half of an incident

    PagerDuty's reputation is built on rotas and escalation. Organisations that keep skipping postmortems, or that run their response in Slack, look at tools designed around the channel, the timeline and the follow-up actions, where the page is one step among several.

02

11 alternatives at a glance

Challengers first, then established names
AlternativeHeadquartersFree optionPricing Key differenceSwitch ifOur rank
ilertGermanyYesFree plan up to 5 users; paid per user per month, publishedGerman-hosted on-call and escalation with a free plan and published pricesyou want hosting in Germany and a published price, and can live with grouping on the higher plan#1
Xurrent IMR (formerly Zenduty)IndiaNo free tierPer user per month, published; 14-day trial onlyThe former Zenduty: alert routing with grouping and playbooks on every planyou are a startup that needs noise control without an enterprise contract#3
All QuietGermanyNo free tierPer user per month, published; 14-day trialBerlin-built on-call and incident management with per-user prices publishedyou manage rotas as code and want calls included in the seat#2
SolarWinds Incident Response (formerly Squadcast)IndiaNo free tierPer user per month, published; 14-day trial onlyThe former Squadcast: on-call and reliability workflow at a published pricecost is the reason and you are comfortable buying from SolarWinds#6
incident.ioUnited KingdomYesFree Basic plan; paid per user per month, published; on-call priced on topRuns the whole incident inside the Slack or Teams channel it createdyour weak point is what happens after the page, in Slack or Teams#4
Better StackCzechiaYesFree tier; per responder and per monitor, publishedUptime checks, on-call and status page bought as one thingyou are a small team with no monitoring in place yet#5
FireHydrantUnited StatesYesFree plan up to 10 responders; Pro per responder per month, published; Signals billed by alerts sentRunbooks that execute the process while the incident is runningunclear service ownership is what slows your incidents#8
RootlyUnited StatesNo free tierPer user per month, published; Enterprise on requestChat-driven incident response with heavy workflow automationyou want incident administration automated inside Slack and have an owner for it#9
SIGNL4GermanyYesFree plan for up to 5 users; paid plans per user per month, publishedMobile alerting for teams that are not sitting at a deskyou need alerts to reach field or operations staff on a phone, not only engineers#7
AlertOpsUnited StatesYesPer user per month, published; free tierRouting rules for organisations with awkward escalation politicsyou want ITSM integrations and a small free tier, and your team stays under ten responders#11
xMattersUnited StatesYesFree tier; per user per month published, enterprise quotedEnterprise notification and escalation now inside Everbridgeyou run a large multilingual estate and want a workflow builder behind the paging#12
03

What each one does differently

ilert

Germany · Free plan up to 5 users; paid per user per month, published

ilert is a German company with hosting in Germany and a free plan for up to 5 users. Pro is listed at 19 per user per month billed yearly, in USD or EUR, with unlimited SMS and voice alerts and single sign-on; Scale, at 39, adds intelligent alert grouping and major incident management. Call routing and AIOps are priced add-ons.

Switch from PagerDuty if you want hosting in Germany and a published price, and can live with grouping on the higher plan.

ilert, #1 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

Xurrent IMR (formerly Zenduty)

India · Per user per month, published; 14-day trial only

Zenduty is now sold as Xurrent IMR. It lists alert correlation, advanced suppression and playbooks on every plan, the capabilities PagerDuty prices separately. Starter is USD 6 per user per month for up to 5 seats and one team; Growth is USD 16 for up to 50 seats with unlimited integrations.

Switch from PagerDuty if you are a startup that needs noise control without an enterprise contract.

Xurrent IMR (formerly Zenduty), #3 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

All Quiet

Germany · Per user per month, published; 14-day trial

All Quiet's Standard plan includes unlimited SMS, phone calls and integrations at USD 4.99 per user per month. The Terraform provider, public REST API, single sign-on with OIDC and SCIM, status pages and live call routing come with Pro at USD 9.99. It offers US and EU regions and a 14-day trial, with no free plan.

Switch from PagerDuty if you manage rotas as code and want calls included in the seat.

All Quiet, #2 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

SolarWinds Incident Response (formerly Squadcast)

India · Per user per month, published; 14-day trial only

Squadcast is now SolarWinds Incident Response. It reproduces PagerDuty's mechanics: escalations, postmortems and basic event intelligence on Pro at USD 15 per user per month billed annually. Premium, at USD 24, adds unlimited SMS and voice, the SLO tracker and status pages. Intelligent alert grouping is an Enterprise feature, and Pro caps free notifications per user.

Switch from PagerDuty if cost is the reason and you are comfortable buying from SolarWinds.

SolarWinds Incident Response (formerly Squadcast), #6 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

incident.io

United Kingdom · Free Basic plan; paid per user per month, published; on-call priced on top

incident.io starts from the response, not the page: it opens the channel in Slack or Microsoft Teams, assigns roles, chases updates and drafts the postmortem. Team is USD 15 per user per month on annual billing, with on-call a further USD 10; on-call alone is USD 20. A free Basic plan exists.

Switch from PagerDuty if your weak point is what happens after the page, in Slack or Teams.

incident.io, #4 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

Better Stack

Czechia · Free tier; per responder and per monitor, published

Better Stack bundles uptime checks with on-call, unlimited phone and SMS alerts and a status page, so it supplies the monitoring that PagerDuty only receives alerts from. A responder licence is USD 29 per month billed yearly with 10 monitors included, and a free tier covers 10 monitors with Slack and email alerts.

Switch from PagerDuty if you are a small team with no monitoring in place yet.

Better Stack, #5 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

FireHydrant

United States · Free plan up to 10 responders; Pro per responder per month, published; Signals billed by alerts sent

FireHydrant centres on a service catalogue and runbooks that execute the process: create the channel, page the owner, open the ticket. Pro is USD 25 per responder per month billed annually with on-call scheduling; its Signals alerting is billed by alerts sent. Alert grouping and unlimited runbooks are Enterprise features, and a free plan covers 10 responders.

Switch from PagerDuty if unclear service ownership is what slows your incidents.

FireHydrant, #8 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

Rootly

United States · Per user per month, published; Enterprise on request

Rootly runs incident response from Slack with an automation engine that files tickets and drafts retrospectives. It publishes two Essentials plans at USD 20 per user per month each: incident response, and on-call with alert grouping and live call routing included. Enterprise tiers are quoted, and the workflows need someone to maintain them.

Switch from PagerDuty if you want incident administration automated inside Slack and have an owner for it.

Rootly, #9 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

SIGNL4

Germany · Free plan for up to 5 users; paid plans per user per month, published

SIGNL4 is built around mobile alerting rather than a rota-first console. A free Starter plan covers up to 5 users; Notify & Connect is USD 9 per user per month with text and voice included, Optimize is USD 15 on annual billing with escalations and duty scheduling, and Maximize is USD 25 with live call routing. Billing is in euro for European customers, and it does not sell a postmortem workflow.

Switch from PagerDuty if you need alerts to reach field or operations staff on a phone, not only engineers.

SIGNL4, #7 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

AlertOps

United States · Per user per month, published; free tier

AlertOps lists a free plan for up to 5 users, Standard at USD 10 per user per month and Premium at USD 22, with live call routing, workflow automation and SSO only on Premium. It markets itself as an IT operations layer across ITSM tools and as a replacement for Opsgenie. Plan limits cap Standard at 10 users and 3 escalation policies.

Switch from PagerDuty if you want ITSM integrations and a small free tier, and your team stays under ten responders.

AlertOps, #11 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

xMatters

United States · Free tier; per user per month published, enterprise quoted

xMatters is now part of Everbridge and is organised as Free, Starter, Base and Advanced tiers. Push, email and Slack or Teams notifications are unlimited, while SMS and voice are capped per full user per month on paid tiers. It stresses a workflow designer and notification in 42 languages. We could not confirm seat prices from the page.

Switch from PagerDuty if you run a large multilingual estate and want a workflow builder behind the paging.

xMatters, #12 of 13 in our incident management ranking →

04

When PagerDuty is still the right choice

PagerDuty earns its price in large estates where every monitoring tool must already have an integration and a missed page is unacceptable. Its escalation logic handles the awkward rota cases and the phone rings when it should, backed by twenty years of doing so. If on-call reliability outranks the cost of seats, and alert sources are numerous or obscure, cheaper tools add risk for a modest saving.

05

What moving off PagerDuty involves

  1. 01

    Rebuild the escalation policies, then test at night

    Schedules, overrides and escalation steps have to be recreated in the new tool. Afterwards put yourself second on a rota, silence the first responder's phone and see what happens at midnight, including voice calls to every country where responders live.

  2. 02

    Repoint every alert source

    Each monitoring tool currently sends to PagerDuty through an integration. List them all, check the replacement has a native integration for each, and expect the odd ones to arrive by webhook. Set alert keys as you go so repeat firings update one incident.

  3. 03

    Take the incident history with you

    Timelines and postmortems are the record you own after an incident. Export incidents and their timelines as structured data before the contract ends; this is usually an API call, not a download button. Decide where that archive lives if the new tool cannot import it.

06

Questions about replacing PagerDuty

4 answers
What is the cheapest alternative to PagerDuty?

On listed seat prices, All Quiet starts at USD 4.99 per user per month with unlimited calls and SMS, and Xurrent IMR, formerly Zenduty, at USD 6 for up to 5 seats.

PagerDuty Professional is USD 21 billed annually. ilert, incident.io, FireHydrant and Better Stack each have a free tier.

Which PagerDuty alternative includes alert grouping in the base plan?

Xurrent IMR lists alert correlation and suppression on every plan, and Rootly's on-call Essentials plan includes alert grouping.

ilert puts intelligent grouping on its Scale plan, and the former Squadcast and FireHydrant reserve it for Enterprise. PagerDuty Professional excludes it; it needs AIOps or a Reliability Platform tier.

Is incident.io a replacement for PagerDuty?

It can be. incident.io sells on-call on its own at USD 20 per user per month, or as an add-on of USD 10 on the Team plan, which is USD 15 per user on annual billing.

It runs natively in Slack or Microsoft Teams, and a free Basic plan covers a single team.

Can Opsgenie users treat the same tools as PagerDuty alternatives?

Yes, and there is a deadline. Atlassian stopped selling Opsgenie on 4 June 2025 and will shut it down on 5 April 2027, deleting data that has not been moved.

ilert, All Quiet and Xurrent IMR cover the same rota and escalation mechanics at published prices.

—

Sources

Checked 30 September 2026
—

Who wrote this

Last reviewed 9 October 2026

Sebastiaan Smits

Founder · Amsterdam, Netherlands

Founder of The Knowledge Engineers and of 2 Steps Ahead, an AI search visibility agency. Editorially responsible for every page on this site; research and drafting are AI-assisted.

Written, edited and fact-checked by Sebastiaan Smits. Last reviewed 9 October 2026. How we review.

—

PagerDuty head to head

—

Alternatives to other products